top of page
Search

Cave of the Patriarchs: Is this really the place?

Writer: Yoni
Yoni
Oct 30
7 min read

Updated: Nov 10

Herodian enclosure over the Cave of the Patriarchs (Machpelah), Hebron, from the south

The Herodian enclosure over מְעָרַת הַמַּכְפֵּלָה (Cave of the Patriarchs), Hebron, seen from the south.

Stand at the bottom of the steps in Hebron and look up. The great pale wall in front of you, with its rows of flat pilasters, was built in the time of King Herod, more than two thousand years ago. It is the only Herodian building in the country still standing virtually intact. Somewhere beneath it, according to our Sedra this week Chaye Sarah, is the cave Abraham bought from Ephron the Hittite to bury Sarah. There is no archaeological evidence for the burials themselves. But there is a genuine tradition, and the most important piece of evidence: by Herod's day 2000 years ago the site was already ancient and revered, which is why he built this enclosure around it at all.

"Is this really the place?" It is the most natural question at any holy site, and the honest answer is that it depends on the site. The evidence comes in three kinds: what archaeologists dig up, what ancient writers tell us, and what generations of worshippers have handed down.

L'havdil, no archaeological find from their own lifetimes names the originators of Christianity or Islam. The closest for the Gospels is the Pilate Stone, found at Caesarea in 1961, which names Pontius Pilate as prefect of Judea. An ancient ossuary that surfaced in a private collection in 2002 bears an inscription whose key phrase, linking it to the originator of Christianity, is widely doubted; a 2012 forgery trial acquitted its owner without proving it genuine. As for Muhammad, no archaeological find connects him to this land in his lifetime. That does not mean the two faiths left no trace here, it just means the trace came much later after the events attributed to them.

A Christian prayer hall at Megiddo has a mosaic from the 3rd century, the country is full of Byzantine churches, and the Dome of the Rock carries one of the earliest dated Qur'anic inscriptions. But most Christian holy places were identified centuries after the events, above all in the 4th century under Emperor Constantine and his mother Helena. And the Muslim connection to Jerusalem was shaped by politics. The Umayyad caliph Abd al-Malik built the Dome of the Rock in 691–692 while a rival caliph, Ibn al-Zubayr, held Mecca. The 9th-century chronicler al-Ya'qubi wrote that he built it to draw pilgrims away from Mecca, though some modern scholars question that account.

The great Jewish sites of Jerusalem are different, because there the spade, T'nach and the Talmud converge. About הַר הַבַּיִת (the Temple Mount) there is no serious doubt at all. Josephus tells us Herod began rebuilding the Temple in the eighteenth year of his reign, about 20 BCE, and his huge retaining walls, including הַכֹּתֶל הַמַּעֲרָבִי (the Western Wall), are still standing. Benjamin Mazar's excavations turned up a fallen parapet stone at the south-west corner carved with the words לְבֵית הַתְּקִיעָה (to the place of trumpeting), at the very corner where Josephus says a priest blew the trumpet to announce the start and end of שַׁבָּת (the Sabbath).

Walk down into עִיר דָּוִד (the City of David) and it keeps happening. A clay seal impression found on the Ophel reads "Belonging to Hezekiah [son of] Ahaz, king of Judah". And in June 2004, workers repairing a sewer pipe came across two ancient steps. Eli Shukron and Ronny Reich realised they had found the Second Temple-era בְּרֵכַת הַשִּׁלֹחַ (Pool of Siloam), a great stepped pool for ritual purification.

Hannah's prayer sign above the excavations at Tel Shiloh

Hannah's prayer (1 Samuel 2), displayed above the excavations at Tel שִׁילֹה (Shiloh).

Then there is a crown jewel: שִׁילֹה (Shiloh). After the Temple Mount, there are few places where we can say with such a high degree of certainty that this was the site of הַמִּשְׁכָּן (the Tabernacle). If you come on my Shiloh day tour, I'll explain why scholars believe this is the ancient site of Shiloh and of the Tabernacle.

Some sites have old traditions but mixed evidence. קֶבֶר רָחֵל (Rachel's Tomb), on the edge of Bethlehem, follows Genesis 35:19, "on the way to Ephrath, which is Bethlehem". But 1 Samuel 10:2 places her tomb "in the border of Benjamin, at Zelzah", north of Jerusalem. Nachmanides wrestled with exactly this, and after seeing the tomb near Bethlehem accepted the tradition there. It is an ancient one: in 333 CE the Bordeaux Pilgrim, a Christian traveller, already describes Rachel's tomb four miles from Jerusalem on the road to Bethlehem.

And then there are the medieval traditions. קֶבֶר דָּוִד (David's Tomb) on Mount Zion and קֶבֶר שְׁמוּאֵל הַנָּבִיא (the Tomb of Samuel the Prophet), on the high hill north of Jerusalem, both took their present form in the Crusader period, and there is no archaeological evidence that David or Samuel is buried in either. The Tanakh says plainly that David "was buried in the city of David" (1 Kings 2:10), on the ridge south of the Temple Mount, not on the hill we now call Mount Zion. The cenotaph there has been known as David's tomb only since the 12th century. Benjamin of Tudela, the Jewish traveller who toured the land around 1170, tells a wonderful story about how it was found. If you want to hear it, I’ll tell you on my Mount Zion walking tour.

Samuel's tomb has a similar history. The Bible says Samuel was buried "in his house at Ramah" (1 Samuel 25:1). In Byzantine times a monastery was built on the hill in his honour, yet Jerome, writing in Bethlehem in 406, records that Emperor Arcadius had already carried "the bones of the blessed Samuel" from Judea to Constantinople. In June 1099 the Crusaders had their first sight of Jerusalem from this summit and called it the Mount of Joy. Weeks later, on 15 July, they stormed the city and massacred its Muslims and Jews; the Damascus chronicler Ibn al-Qalanisi records that the Jews were burned alive in their synagogue. Benjamin of Tudela tells us what happened next: when the Christians took Ramla, which he took to be biblical Ramah, they found the grave of Samuel near the Jewish synagogue, carried the remains to the hill and built a large church over them.

The same goes for מִגְדַּל דָּוִד (the Tower of David), Jerusalem's Citadel by Jaffa Gate. Its massive lower tower is Herodian, usually identified as Herod's Phasael tower, and the slender minaret most people now call the Tower of David was built by the Ottomans in the 17th century. The name itself was given by Byzantine Christians in the 5th century, who mistook the hill for the site of David's palace.

So what about the sites without historical veracity, like David's Tomb? Is it still important? Yes, though not necessarily because King David is buried there. We don't know for sure. It is possible that his remains could have been moved there at some time in antiquity, but there is no proof or evidence of that.

It commemorates King David. Like a cenotaph, it concentrates our emotions and our spiritual energies on one of the greatest figures of Jewish history. The site has it's own inherent sanctity being part of the original Old City of Jerusalem, albeit outside the Ottoman walls and that sanctity has been magnified by the countless Tefilos and Tehillim (prayers and psalms) that have been and are being recited there constantly.

This is why it matters. We should keep going there, and I will carry on taking people to King David's Tomb on my Mount Zion walking tour in Jerusalem.

Contact Yoni to plan a tour that works for your group.

Am Yisroel Chai

Yoni

(C) All Rights Reserved 2026

Sources: Hebrew Bible: Genesis 23 and 35:19; 1 Samuel 2, 10:2 and 25:1; 1 Kings 2:10; Song of Songs 4:4. Josephus, Antiquities 15.380 and Jewish War 4.582. Bordeaux Pilgrim, Itinerarium Burdigalense (333 CE), trans. A. Jacobs. Jerome, Against Vigilantius 5 (406 CE); Ibn al-Qalanisi, The Damascus Chronicle of the Crusades, trans. H. A. R. Gibb (1932, repr. 2003), p. 48; Raymond of Aguilers, in A. C. Krey, The First Crusade (1921); B. Z. Kedar, "The Jerusalem Massacre of July 1099 in the Western Historiography of the Crusades", Crusades 3 (2004); Paschal Chronicle, s.a. 406 (via The Cult of Saints database, University of Oxford). Benjamin of Tudela, Itinerary, trans. M. N. Adler (1907), on St Samuel and Ramla, and trans. S. Benjamin (1995), on David's tomb (Center for Online Judaic Studies, "Benjamin of Tudela's Second Letter from Jerusalem"). P. M. Briks, "Christian Worship at the Tomb of the Prophet Samuel on Mount Joy". Israel Nature and Parks Authority, "Nebi Samuel Park". Wikipedia, "Nabi Samwil", "Tomb of Samuel", "Tower of David", "Dome of the Rock", "Siege of Jerusalem (1099)", "James Ossuary", "Cave of the Patriarchs", "Rachel's Tomb", "Trumpeting Place inscription" and "Western Wall". D. Bahat, The Carta Jerusalem Atlas (on the Tower of David name). Al-Ya'qubi, Ta'rikh (9th century), on the Dome of the Rock; O. Grabar, "Kubbat al-Sakhra", Encyclopaedia of Islam, 2nd ed. (1986); J. Johns, "Archaeology and the History of Early Islam", JESHO 46 (2003); G. R. Hawting, The First Dynasty of Islam (2000). Encyclopaedia Britannica, "Cave of the Patriarchs". Center for Online Judaic Studies, "The Place of the Trumpeting". Hebrew University / E. Mazar, King Hezekiah seal impression (EurekAlert!, 2015). Biblical Archaeology Review, "The Siloam Pool" (R. Reich and E. Shukron). Jewish Virtual Library, "The Coenaculum on Mount Zion". On the founders: Pilate Stone (A. Frova, 1961); James ossuary (Israel Antiquities Authority 2003 forgery finding; Jerusalem District Court acquittal of O. Golan, 14 March 2012, which explicitly did not rule the inscription authentic); Megiddo prayer-hall mosaics (Y. Tepper, IAA; C. Rollston); Dome of the Rock inscription, 72 AH / 691–692 CE (E. Whelan, Journal of the American Oriental Society 1998).

Image credits: (1) Cave of the Patriarchs, Hebron, from the south, 10 Sept 2009. Photo: Djampa, CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/), via Wikimedia Commons: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Hebron_Cave_of_the_Patriarchs.jpg (2) Hannah's prayer sign overlooking the excavations at Tel Shiloh. Photo: Wow Israel Tours (https://www.wowisraeltours.com/itinerary-shiloh-a).

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page